| Home | Fading Captain Series | GBV News | The Band | The Music | The Critics & Fans | Merchandise | Other Stuff |
Indie Pulse
I
sense a strong need in the indie-rock community for yet another Guided
By Voices review, so here it is. Isolation
Drills is the band's second fully produced
record--and it's a great one. It more than makes up for the Ric Ocasek-produced
disappointment, Do the Collapse,
which actually suffered more from inferior songwriting than it did from
misguided studio wizardry. While every Pollard creation contains moments
of pop genius, Drills
easily becomes the most consistent LP in the band's history, which is
more an observation than a compliment--especially for a band whose
inconsistencies often made it more entertaining. Still, it's exciting to
report that Bob is back at the height of his songwriting prowess and
this time the production accurately reflects what the band sounds like
live.
On
to the songs then. The insanely addictive "Chasing Heather
Crazy" and "Glad Girls" challenge radio to ignore them,
which they will, but it's not for lack of properly placed and repeated
choruses. I suppose it's OK for a 42-year-old father to still be writing
girl songs, isn't it? It has been well documented that this is an
introspective record for Pollard, who has drank and toured himself into
a lonely apartment, and the LP seems fueled by an unrepentant,
reinvigorated sense of purpose. This doesn't mean Bob's core approach to
his music has changed much. "How's my drinking?" tells us that
the Bob Pollard we've come to love isn't going anywhere: "I don't
care about being sober…I won't change." For fans of a man
destined to someday be appreciatively carted into pop heaven by a team
of Budweiser Clydesdales, this is great news. Tight
pop songs are always welcome, but examples of what makes Isolation
Drills compelling are found on
"Twilight Campfighter" and "The Brides Have Hit
Glass." While it's unclear exactly what reservoir these songs are
tapped from (ambiguity cannot be edited out by a producer), there is an
emotional resonance to them that reminds me of REM's Automatic
for the People. Not coincidentally, Pollard's
singing has often been compared to Michael Stipe's. ("Fine to See
You" also fits that record.) "Fair Touching" drifts back
further than that with a hook reminiscent of Fables
of the Reconstruction's "Driver 8."
Comparisons are not criticisms for Pollard. He'd be the first to
acknowledge his love of bands like REM and, more importantly, the Who.
If "Skills Like This" isn't a lost Tommy
track, then it's a brilliant interpretation of classic-period Townshend.
Pollard is as much a fan of pop music history as anyone, and he's not
afraid to call upon it for inspiration. While such an approach would
sink some bands, it propels Pollard's unique vision of what a pop song
can be within traditional parameters. What has always made Voices
special is the combination of classic riffery and lyrical ingenuity, the
latter an area where Pollard is nearly unparalleled. So, there you have
it for the umpteenth time--the reaffirmation of GBV's greatness. In
living stereo, no less. |